Why randomized trials for proton therapy are difficult to complete

Why randomized trials for proton therapy are difficult to complete

October 05, 2018
Rad Oncology Proton Therapy
From the October 2018 issue of HealthCare Business News magazine

By Dr. Justin E. Bekelman

Randomized, controlled clinical trials are the gold standard of cancer research and can shed light on whether innovative, new therapies with great potential actually have clear benefits over usual care for patients. However, the seven randomized trials funded by the National Cancer Institute (NCI) and the Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) to test proton therapy are enrolling more slowly than expected. Commercial insurance medical policies that do not cover treatment with proton therapy can make it difficult for patients to participate in randomized clinical trials funded by the NCI, part of the National Institutes of Health, that are evaluating the therapy. This is the biggest barrier these trials face, but as my colleagues and I recently laid out in a commentary in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, there are concrete steps we can take to improve this situation.

The best diagnostic nuclear imaging systems, parts and service available

Universal Medical provides the very best new & refurbished gamma cameras, quality parts & repair services. We also rebuild & replace camera detectors, move camera systems across town or across the country. Call us at 888-239-3510


It's important to note at the outset that most commercial insurers and state Medicaid plans do not cover proton therapy for the cancers under study in these seven trials, though Medicare typically does through local coverage determinations. While coverage policy is an important tool that can reduce inappropriate use of medical technologies, it can also create barriers to evidence development: in the case of proton therapy, coverage policies on proton therapy prevent patients from participating in the seven randomized clinical trials sponsored by the NCI and PCORI and specifically designed to answer crucial questions about the treatment’s benefits and harms.

We need evidence from these seven trials to determine whether proton therapy is better than usual care at reducing side effects, extending survival, or both. The evidence to date includes studies that have shown benefits to proton therapy as well as studies that have demonstrated expected or sometimes unexpected toxicities in certain cancers.

Currently, six of these randomized trials comparing proton therapy to photon (X-ray) therapy are funded by the NCI, with the seventh funded by PCORI. All of these trials have faced enrollment challenges. For example, in the RadComp trial for breast cancer, nearly two-thirds of eligible patients have insurance coverage policies that do not cover proton therapy for breast cancer; thus, the majority of eligible patients for RadComp cannot actually enroll and participate in the clinical study. While it is true that Medicare typically does cover proton therapy, thus allowing patients to participate in trials, inclusion of only Medicare-eligible patients over 65 significantly limits the number of patients who can participate in the trials and may reduce the generalizability of the results.

You Must Be Logged In To Post A Comment