DOTmed Home MRI Oncology Ultrasound Molecular Imaging X-Ray Cardiology Health IT Business Affairs
News Home Parts & Service Operating Room CT Women's Health Proton Therapy Endoscopy HTMs Mobile Imaging
SEARCH
Aktueller Standort:
>
> This Story


Log in oder Register to rate this News Story
Forward Printable StoryPrint Comment

 

 

Oncology Homepage

Hitachi to install its first single-room compact proton therapy system Reduces footprint to 70 percent of conventional systems

New PET imaging method may yield benefits over FDG for detecting certain cancers Gallium-68-labeled FAPI tracer yields promising results

Israeli startup Alpha Tau Medical raises $29 million for novel radiotherapy New brachytherapy approach could be useful for treating several cancers

Dr. Carri Glide-Hurst American Association of Physicists in Medicine elects fellow

Cecilia Danckwardt-Lillieström C-RAD appoints new CFO

Fox Chase Cancer Center gets $673K grant to develop early-stage lung cancer test Taking aim at false positive CT lung scans

Radiotherapy may cause gaps in memory recall for children, says study Trouble recalling specifics of events after treatment

New brachytherapy approach deemed safe for clinical trials First alpha radiation-based cancer treatment for solid tumors

Radiotherapy vacancies rise above three percent, says ASRT survey Vacancies highest in Pacific region of U.S.

AI model strikes balance between dose toxicity and tumor reduction Minimizes dose while still shrinking tumor

For this cancer, proton therapy is no better than IMRT

by John R. Fischer , Staff Reporter
Proton therapy (PT) may not be a safer bet compared to conventional radiation when it comes to lowering toxicity associated with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

At least that’s what researchers at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center and Massachusetts General Hospital say in a new study comparing dose distribution of 3-D passive scattering proton therapy (PT) and intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), finding no decline in risks, such as radiation pneumonitis, when using the former type of treatment. Their findings were published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.

Story Continues Below Advertisement

OR Tables, Treatment/GYN/Uro Chairs, Transport Stretchers, Hospital/ICU Bed

iMS combines the superior service of Oakworks Medical and advanced manufacturing technology of FAMED Medical Solutions. The goal of iMS, "Connecting Art and Medical Science" goes way beyond product with exceptional CareLink service. Contact us today!



“There is no doubt that there is dosimetric advantage in protons compared with photons. Whether the dosimetric advantage will translated to clinical benefit or not depends on many factors including how best use this new form of radiation," Dr. Zhongxing Liao, the lead author of the study and a professor of Radiation Oncology at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, told HCB News. "Our trial showed that, using an outdated way, passively scattered proton beam or 3-D conformal proton, to deliver proton, we were not able to realize the dosimetric advantage of the proton on lung; therefore, we did not reduce radiation pneumonitis."

The presumption that proton therapy is superior to conventional radiation due to its more-targeted form of delivery have led some to conclude that randomized trials comparing the two are unnecessary, inappropriate and unethical.

Researchers tested this hypothesis in a Bayesian trial in which 149 patients with inoperable NSCLC were randomly selected to undergo IMRT or PSPT with the objective being to determine if PSPT patients showed a lower risk of grade ≥ 3 RP or local failure (LF).

PSPT was found to expose less lung tissue at 5-10 GY (RBE) doses but more at doses of 20 GY (RBE) or higher. No benefits in grade ≥ 3 RP or LF were found in these patients with locally advanced NSCLC.

A one-year follow-up found the PSPT group had a 10.5 percent rate of ≥ 3 RP compared with 6.5 percent of IMRT patients.

Rates of LF were 10.9 percent at one year for patients who underwent IMRT, compared to 10.5 percent of PSPT patients. Combined RP and LF rates at one year were 17.4 percent and 21.1 percent following IMRT and PSPT, respectively.

Though not the main focus, median survival for PSPT patients was 26.1 months and for IMRT, 29.5.

The findings here could make many skeptical of growth predictions for the proton therapy market, which is expected to almost double in value by 2022. They also contrast with a recent study that compared PT and IMRT in the treatment of prostate cancer, finding higher survival rates and less complications induced by radiation exposure among patients who underwent PT.

“The trial tells us that, when investing for proton centers, one needs to be aware of the issues encountered in our trial and be prepared to address them," said Liao. "Adequate engineering, physics, clinical and research support is critical to ensure the success of the proton centers.”

Despite these results, the use of PSPT was found to reduce heart exposure to radiation at levels between 5 and 80 Gy, as well as heart volume, with its impact on cardiac toxicity and overall survival currently under study.

Sparing the heart for overall survival is currently being evaluated in a phase III randomized lung trial that will provide evidence on the use of proton therapy for lung cancer, while a phase II study is comparing the effects of IMRT to the next-generation proton technique intensity-modulated proton therapy. Both will help in providing more information on the comparisons between proton therapy and photon treatments.

Oncology Homepage


You Must Be Logged In To Post A Comment

Werben
Erhöhen Sie Ihren Bekanntheitsgrad
Auktionen + Privatverkäufe
Den besten Preis erzielen
Geräte/Geräteteile kaufen
Den günstigsten Preis finden
Daily News
Die neuesten Nachrichten lesen
Übersicht
Alle DOTmed Benutzer durchsuchen
Ethik auf DOTmed
Unseren Ethik-Standard anzeigen
Gold-Parts Verkäufer-Programm
PH-Anfragen erhalten
Gold Service Dealer-Programm
Anfragen empfangen
Gesundheitsdienstleister
Alle Gesundheitsdienstleister-Tools anzeigen
Jobs/Training
Einen Job suchen
Parts Hunter +EasyPay
Angebote für Geräteteile erhalten
Kürzlich zertifiziert
Kürzlich zertifizierte Benutzer anzeigen
Kürzlich bewertet
Kürzlich zertifizierte Benutzer anzeigen
Rental Central
Geräte billiger mieten
Geräte/Geräteteile verkaufen
Das meiste Geld erhalten
Service-Techniker Forum
Hilfe und Beratung finden
Einfache Angebots-Anfrage
Angebote für Geräte erhalten
Virtuelle Messe
Service für Geräte finden
Access and use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions of our LEGAL NOTICE & PRIVACY NOTICE
Property of and Proprietary to DOTmed.com, Inc. Copyright ©2001-2018 DOTmed.com, Inc.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED